If a driver hit you while looking at a phone, you probably have two questions. Do I actually need a lawyer for this? And how would anyone prove what the other driver was doing with their hands a few seconds before the crash? This guide answers both, using California law as it stands today.
Some context first. NHTSA counted 3,208 people killed and 315,167 injured in crashes involving distracted drivers in 2024. Those are only the crashes where distraction was identified. Many more go unrecorded, because a driver who was texting rarely says so to the officer.
Do I need a lawyer after a distracted driving crash?
Not always. If the damage is limited to a bumper, nobody was hurt, and the other driver's insurer accepts fault in writing, you can usually handle the property claim yourself. Plenty of people do.
The picture changes when any of these are true:
- You were injured and are still treating, or a doctor has mentioned surgery, injections or months of therapy.
- The other driver denies using a phone, or says you caused the crash.
- The insurer wants a recorded statement, or has already offered a quick check before your treatment is finished.
- The at-fault driver was working (a delivery or rideshare driver, a company vehicle, a truck).
- Your medical bills are getting close to the other driver's policy limits.
Distracted driving cases have a specific weakness: the proof that matters most is held by other people. Phone carriers, app companies, the other driver's car and nearby businesses all have records that can show what happened, and some of that data is overwritten or deleted on a schedule. Someone has to ask for it, in the right legal form, quickly. That is the main reason people bring in a lawyer for these cases, more than the negotiation at the end.
What California law says about phones behind the wheel
Two Vehicle Code sections do most of the work.
Vehicle Code 23123 bars driving while using a wireless phone unless it is designed and configured for hands-free listening and talking, and is used that way. It has exceptions, including emergency calls and driving on private property.
Vehicle Code 23123.5 is the broader rule, and the one that covers texting, scrolling and apps. A driver may not hold and operate a handheld phone or other wireless device unless it is used in a voice-operated, hands-free way. There is one narrow allowance: the phone may be mounted on the windshield, dashboard or center console, and the driver may activate or deactivate a feature with a single swipe or tap. Typing a message on a phone in your lap is a violation. So is holding the phone to check a map.
Drivers under 18 face a stricter rule. Vehicle Code 23124 bars them from using a phone while driving even with a hands-free setup.
The penalties look small. Each of these is an infraction with a base fine of $20 for a first offense and $50 after that, and under Vehicle Code 12810.3 a violation point goes on the driver's record when the conviction comes within 36 months of a prior one for the same offense. The fines are not what matters in an injury claim, though. What matters is how the violation is used to prove fault.
Why a phone violation helps your injury claim
California's Evidence Code 669 creates a presumption that a driver failed to use due care if they broke a safety statute, the violation caused the injury, the injury is the kind the law was meant to prevent, and the injured person is someone the law was meant to protect. Phone laws exist to prevent crashes, and other drivers, passengers and pedestrians are the people they protect. If you can prove the other driver was violating 23123.5 at the moment of impact, the burden shifts and they have to explain why they were still acting reasonably. That is a hard argument to make with a phone in your hand.
One thing people get wrong: a traffic ticket, or even a conviction, does not settle the civil case by itself. Vehicle Code 40834 says a conviction for a Vehicle Code violation is not binding on any issue in a later civil lawsuit. The citation helps. The injury claim still has to prove the distraction with evidence.
How phone use is proved
Hardly anyone admits it. So the case gets built from records and witnesses, usually several sources that point the same way.
Phone carrier records
Carriers keep logs of calls, texts and data sessions with timestamps. In a civil case these are usually obtained by subpoena. Federal law matters here: under the Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. 2702, a carrier may release non-content records, such as the time and length of a call or the fact that a text was sent, to a private party, but it generally will not hand over the content of messages without the account holder's consent. In practice that is enough. A text sent at 4:12:30 and a 911 call logged at 4:12:41 tell a jury most of the story.
Expect a fight over scope. Courts weigh the other driver's privacy, so a request for months of phone history will likely be narrowed to a window around the crash. A tight, well-reasoned request tends to get answered faster than a broad one.
The phone and the apps on it
Carrier logs do not show everything. Social media posts, messaging apps that run over data, streaming and navigation activity can all leave timestamps on the device itself or with the app company. In a serious case, a forensic examination of the phone, done under a court order or agreed protocol, can show screen activity and unlock events right before impact. If the driver was working for a delivery or rideshare platform, the company's own trip and app logs may show whether the driver was accepting an order at that moment.
Crash data from the vehicles
Most modern cars carry an event data recorder. California's Vehicle Code 9951 lists what these devices can capture, including speed, direction, steering and whether the brakes were applied before a crash. A recorder that shows full speed and no braking until impact is consistent with a driver who never saw the stopped traffic ahead. The same section limits who can download that data: generally the registered owner, someone with the owner's consent, or anyone acting under a court order. That is one reason to move early, before the other car is repaired, sold or crushed.
Witnesses, video and the police report
Witnesses often notice a driver looking down, or see a phone light up in the cabin. Get names and phone numbers at the scene if you can, because people scatter fast. Nearby businesses, buses and doorbell cameras record over their footage on short cycles, sometimes within days, so a written request to preserve video is worth sending right away. The officer's report (in many crashes, a CHP 555) may also note a phone on the seat or floor, or a statement the driver made at the scene.
The physical evidence
Crash patterns can support the record evidence. Drifting across a lane line, a rear-end impact with no skid, or a late reaction at a light that had been red for several seconds all fit a distracted driver. On their own these facts prove little. Combined with a text sent seconds earlier, they are strong.
What if I was partly at fault?
You can still bring a claim. California uses pure comparative fault, adopted by the California Supreme Court in Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975). Your recovery is reduced by your share of the blame, but it is not wiped out. If a jury finds the texting driver 80 percent responsible and you 20 percent responsible for, say, a late lane change, you can recover 80 percent of your damages.
This is also where insurers push hardest. Expect them to argue that you were speeding, that you stopped suddenly, or that you were on your own phone. Those arguments are one more reason to collect the other driver's phone records: proof of their distraction makes it harder to shift blame onto you. And do not guess about fault in a recorded statement. Say what you saw and leave the percentages to the evidence.
Deadlines you should know
- Two years to file a lawsuit for personal injury in most California cases, under Code of Civil Procedure 335.1.
- Six months to present a written claim if a public entity shares fault, for example a city bus driver or a government vehicle (Government Code 911.2).
- Much sooner for evidence. Phone records, app logs and surveillance video are kept for limited periods. Preservation letters go out in the first days or weeks, not near the filing deadline.
What to do in the first few days
- Get medical care and follow through on it. Gaps in treatment are the first thing an adjuster looks for.
- Write down what you saw: the phone in the driver's hand, a glow on their face, something they said. Do it while it is fresh.
- Keep your photos, the other driver's information, the report number and witness contacts in one place.
- Do not give the other driver's insurer a recorded statement until you know the full extent of your injuries.
- Do not post about the crash online. Your own posts can be requested too.
Talking to a lawyer
If you were hurt and suspect the other driver was on a phone, a consultation costs nothing and usually answers the main question: is this worth pursuing, and what evidence needs to be locked down now. Our California distracted driving accident attorneys page explains how Saeedian Law Group handles these claims, from preservation letters and subpoenas to negotiation and trial. Every case turns on its own facts, and no lawyer can predict how one will turn out.
Contact Saeedian Law Group or call (310) 288-3000 for a free case review. We work on contingency, so there is no fee unless we recover compensation for you.